WriteCheck Blog

Filtering by Tag: plagiarism at harvard

Written by Jonathan Bailey, author of Plagiarism Today

Earlier, we talked about how 125 Harvard students were being students were being brought before the schools Administrative Board on allegations of plagiarism. However, now more details are coming out regarding how the scandal was detected and how it unfolded.

According to Harvard’s school newspaper, The Harvard Crimson, the scandal began to unfold in May when assistant professor Matthew B. Platt sent a letter to the Administrative Board noting similarities in 13 take home exams.

Platt, who was grading the exams given to students in an “Introduction to Congress” course, said he noticed similarities between many of the tests including a strings of similar words, a typo and an unnecessary space in a number, that prompted him to take action.

To make matters worse, Platt also noticed that all of the exams in question used, “The same (incorrect) reading of the course material” and also structured their arguments in an identical manner. In fact, the exams used the same two “somewhat obscure” examples to answer the question.

It was Platt’s letter that started the Administrative Board’s investigation into the case and that investigation quickly ballooned from the from the original 13 to 125 exams. According to The Crimson, that number represents nearly half of the class involved and approximately two percent (2%) of Harvard’s total student body.

But even as the fallout from the scandal continues to settle, including the sidelining of the captain of the school’s men’s basketball team, the case has come to highlight how there are many different ways in which students who engage in academic dishonesty can be caught.

Though technology has made it easier than ever to spot copied text, many cases of plagiarism are still caught in more traditional ways. This includes students who have a sudden change in writing style, formatting issues or, as with this case, repeating the same mistakes as others.

In short, while originality detection is a major part of locating and stopping plagiarism in classrooms, it isn’t the only tool that is used. Common sense and observation are still the most powerful tools an instructor has and that makes it imperative for students to be careful with their assignments regardless of whether or not their school uses an automated system.

If 125 Harvard students can get brought before the Administrative Board because an assistant professor noticed similarities while grading tests, then any student at any other school can meet the same fate.

This is why students need to be aware of the dangers involved with turning in sloppy work and be vigilant in not plagiarizing, either intentionally or unintentionally, regardless of what their school is doing at the time.

Related

Harvard students investigated in unprecedented plagiarism scandal

Common Grammar Mistakes

Categories

Current Events

Published on by Guest.

No Comments

Committing plagiarism isn’t often a one time offense that simply goes away.  Like many other infractions and crimes, a bad case of plagiarism is something that can re-emerge and cause havoc for an individual or business throughout their lifetime.

Case in point: Adam Wheeler.  The 25 year old is now infamous for faking his way into Harvard through fraud and plagiarism.  He ended up getting caught and sentenced to 2.5 years in jail and 10 years of probation, although he only ended up serving one month in jail. However, Wheeler recently broke the terms of his probation by using Harvard on his resume when applying to a job.  The repercussion for this will most likely be Wheeler having to serve the remainder of his sentence in jail.

Many are questioning Wheeler’s judgment and overall ‘moral compass’:  why in the world would he risk breaking his probation with such an obvious and public lie?

Despite the seemingly risky act, there is a chance Wheeler may have ‘accidentally’ left the false information on his resume. Either way, he’s guilty of breaking probation.  This just goes to show that an act of plagiarism or fraud can follow someone beyond the initial fallout – it’s not something that is easily forgotten by the world (or legal system).

The names on this ‘plagiarism blacklist’ go on and on – even if they weren’t formally charged with a crime, the long term ‘brand’ damage that comes with an incident can often be irreparable.  Stephen Glass, who was infamous for his plagiarism scandal at The New Republic, is another prime example.  After the initial scandal fallout, Glass tried to move on with his life and enter the field of law.  He did successfully get his law degree from Georgetown; however, Glass also applied to the California bar association and was denied due to ‘his history of ethical problems.’  These problems will likely follow Glass around for the entirety of his life (probably also due to the popularized movie ‘Shattered Glass’ that portrayed his story).

These aren’t just stories that have happened to other people; they are lessons to be learned. Plagiarism is a huge risk that isn’t about one confined incident – it can be a permanent mark on a person’s reputation that prevents future opportunities throughout their life.

Citations

Crimesider Staff.  “Harvard wannabe tries again, lies again, puts school on resume.”  CBS News.  November 11th, 2011.  http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504083_162-57322651-504083/harvard-wannabe-tries-again-lies-again-puts-school-on-resume/

Wikipedia. October 7th 2011.  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Glass_(reporter)

Categories

Current Events

Published on by davidr.

1 Comment